How To Choose Durable Pet Toys That Can Survive Your Dog

Dogs bring endless joy, but that joy can take a toll on your wallet, especially when you're constantly replacing destroyed toys. If you feel like you've spent more time picking up shredded toy pieces than playing fetch lately, you're not alone.

Many dog owners suffer the same fate of constantly buying new toys only to see their pets decimate them in a matter of days. If you’re the owner of a canine that loves to make it their mission to destroy toys, we’ll show you how to choose durable pet toys that can survive your dog below.

Understanding Your Dog’s Play Style

Before shopping for durable pet toys, take the time to understand your dog's specific play habits. Not every dog plays the same way, and understanding how your dog likes to enjoy their toys will help you pick toys that better suit their play style and may survive longer.

What Kind of Player Is Your Dog?

Depending on their breed and individual personality, your dog may prefer to play by chewing, fetching, or tugging with other dogs or their owner. Observe your dog’s playtime, and you’ll likely notice that they fall into one of these categories:

• The Enthusiastic Chewer: This dog sees every toy as a chew challenge they must vanquish. Plush toys rarely survive more than a few days with these dogs, especially if they’re larger breeds.
• The Fetch Fanatic: If your dog is a type of collie, retriever, poodle, or shepherd, they likely love fetch and never tire of it. They’ll return anything you throw, but something lightweight and easy to grab is best for these dogs.
• The Tug-of-War Champ: Highly energetic and focused breeds, such as collies, bullies, and terriers, usually love playing tug-of-war with their owner or other dogs. You’ll want a toy or rope of strong fabrics to handle the gnawing and tugging.
• The Gentle Handler: If your dog is playful but also gentle in how it plays, you don’t have to worry much about durability and have a wide range of toys to choose from.

Materials Matter: What to Look for in Durable Toys

Not all pet supplies and toys are equal, and what they’re made of greatly affects their lifespan. Durable materials, such as industrial-grade rubber, high-strength nylon, or tightly woven natural fibers, are excellent options for dogs who put their toys through the wringer.

Rubber Toys for Vigorous Chewers

Rubber toys are especially great for vigorous chewers. KONG toys are popular amongst dog owners because they are nearly indestructible and offer the bonus of treat-stuffing features to mentally stimulate your dog and reward them while they play.

Nylon and Hard Plastic Toys

Nylon or hard plastic toys are also excellent choices for dogs who enjoy gnawing. Look for toys labeled as "chew-proof" or "designed for power chewers" to ensure they withstand heavy use.

Choosing Tough Plush Toys

Plush toys are cute, and many dogs love them, but they’re not very durable. If you get a plush toy for your dog, focus on those with reinforced seams and thicker stitching. While no soft toy is completely indestructible, some brands specialize in creating tougher plush toys for moderate chewers. Squeakers and crinkle materials inside these toys can engage your dog without falling apart quickly.

Materials to Avoid

Avoid brittle plastics or cheap fabrics that can splinter or tear easily. These materials can break into pieces, posing a risk of injury to your pet. Always prioritize safety and durability when choosing toys.

Size and Shape Considerations

While the cutest toy on the shelf may draw your eye, size and shape are far more important than aesthetics when selecting a dog toy. The best approach is to choose a toy that matches your dog’s size and breed.

For larger dogs, small toys can present a choking hazard and may not withstand the strength of their jaws. On the other hand, toys that are too big for smaller breeds can be cumbersome and difficult for them to enjoy.

Shape and Engagement

The shape of a toy also plays a significant role in how your dog interacts with it. Spherical toys, such as tennis balls, are ideal for dogs who love to fetch. However, these toys may not hold up well with heavy chewers.

Irregularly shaped toys engage dogs with their unpredictable bounces and variety of textures, making them perfect for energetic pups. By focusing on size and shape, you can select toys that are not only fun but also safe and long-lasting for your dog.

Tips for Extending the Lifespan of Pet Toys

Now that you know how to choose durable pet toys that can survive your dog, you’ll need to learn how to make them last. Even the toughest toys will eventually succumb to playtime, but with proper care, you can make them last much longer. Follow these tips to keep your dog's toys in great shape.

1. Clean Regularly

Dirt and bacteria can break down toy materials over time, so regular cleaning is essential. For rubber and nylon toys, hand-wash them yourself or place them in the dishwasher if they’re marked safe for the dishwasher. For fabric and plush toys, spot-clean them as needed and follow the washing instructions on the label.

2. Rotate Toys

Just like you rotate the tires on your car to keep their use and wear even, consider a pet toy rotation. This keeps toys "new" and exciting, preventing boredom and reducing wear on any single toy. A small collection of favorites is all you need.

3. Supervise During Playtime

Always supervise your dog during play to ensure safety and toy longevity. If you see your dog biting off or swallowing materials, take the toy away immediately to avoid ingesting hazardous materials.

Dog Toys to Avoid

When selecting toys for your dog, be cautious about the materials and designs that could pose a danger. Avoid toys with tiny, detachable parts that a dog could easily swallow or choke on. Similarly, keep your dog away from toys with low-quality materials that may crack or break apart, such as brittle plastic or poorly sewn seams.

Additionally, avoid toys with strings or ribbons, as dogs can become tangled or ingest the material, causing serious health issues. Always prioritize durable, non-toxic options specifically for pets to ensure your furry friend’s playtime is both fun and safe.

Invest in Fun That Lasts at Yeager’s Sporting Goods

Choosing durable pet toys not only saves money but also keeps your dog safe and enhances their playtime. By understanding your dog’s play style, choosing sturdy materials, and selecting the right size, you can ensure a better experience. Visit Yeager’s Sporting Goods for expertly curated, durable toys that your furry friend will love.